Choosing a Grassfed Steak That Fits Your Meal

Ribeye, filet mignon, sirloin or New York strip? I start with the kind of steak I want, then the portion that fits the meal. Here’s a simple way to choose.


By Chris Baggott
3 min read

Ribeye steaks cooking over an open fire at the Churchtown Dairy tasting.

I eat our beef regularly, and I don’t think choosing a steak needs to turn into a test of how much you know about a butcher’s counter. You can start with something much simpler: what do you enjoy eating, and how much steak do you want on your plate?

Ribeye, filet mignon, sirloin and New York strip all come from different parts of the animal. That gives them different characteristics. The most expensive cut isn’t automatically the right one for your meal, and a larger steak isn’t automatically a better choice.

Here’s how I’d think through the choices in our farm store.

Ribeye for a richer steak

Ribeye comes from the rib section. It’s the cut to consider if you enjoy the richness that comes with marbling, the fat within the meat. Every animal is a little different, so two ribeyes won’t necessarily look exactly alike.

Our ribeye page offers weight ranges rather than pretending every steak is identical. Look at the size you’re selecting as well as the name of the cut. If you’re sharing a steak, that may lead you to a different package than you’d choose for one person.

Filet mignon when tenderness comes first

Filet mignon comes from the tenderloin, a muscle that does relatively little work. That’s why tenderness is its calling card. It’s also a lean cut, so it offers a different experience from a ribeye.

We offer a 5-ounce filet and a 7-ounce filet. I like that people can choose the portion that fits their appetite without changing the cut they enjoy. There’s no reason everyone at the table needs the same size steak.

Sirloin for a leaner choice

Our regular sirloin steak is a top sirloin cut. It’s a good option when you want a leaner steak with plenty of beef character. It has its own texture rather than trying to be a filet.

The regular sirloin is listed at approximately 8 to 10 ounces. That’s useful information when you’re comparing packages. A familiar cut name tells you one thing; the amount you’re actually buying tells you another.

New York strip for another familiar option

New York strip comes from the short loin. It’s a boneless steak with a distinct beef flavor, and it’s worth considering alongside ribeye and sirloin rather than overlooking it because you already have a favorite.

Our regular strip is listed at approximately 10 to 12 ounces. If you’re comparing it with a filet, remember that you’re comparing both a different cut and a different portion. Looking at those separately makes the decision clearer.

Ribeye steaks cooking on a grill over flames.

100% GRASSFED & GRASS-FINISHED

Find the steak that fits your table

Ribeye, filet, sirloin or New York strip. Choose the cut you enjoy and the portion that fits your meal.

Shop Grassfed Steaks

Start with the meal you actually want

I’d choose the character of the steak first, then the package size. Richer ribeye, tender filet, leaner sirloin or a New York strip: there’s room for more than one good answer. You don’t need a special occasion or a freezer full of beef to buy from our farm.

The common thread is how we raise the cattle. Our beef is 100% grassfed and grass-finished here in Indiana. The cut changes; that commitment doesn’t. For those of you who already buy from us, thank you. Your orders support the work behind every package.

You can find each of these cuts in our online store. Check the current size and availability, and enter your ZIP code to see the pickup, local-delivery or shipping options available to you. Local delivery and paid frozen shipping are different services, so use the options shown for your address.

Choose what fits your table. That’s a perfectly good place to start.


Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.