The Changing Requirements Behind Organic

The Changing Requirements Behind Organic

At Tyner Pond Farm, we’ve been going above and beyond rules required for “organic” certification since we were founded, and we plan to continue to do so. We never use hormones or antibiotics, even though organic rules permit some use of antibiotics. We’ve always given our animals open grasslands to roam and forage. We believe that treating animals right is good for the animals, good for the land, and good for our customers.


We wanted to provide a bit of context to the changing requirements behind organic so you can make better decisions about the meat you purchase. On January 18, 2017, the Obama administration finalized the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s rules for the requirements of the Organic label.

The new rules codify practices that a lot of people took for granted in organic meats. The new rules address two goals:

  • “To ensure that organic farms and businesses are consistently applying organic regulations for livestock and poultry operations”

  • “To assure consumers that organically produced products meet a consistent standard, which will support consumer confidence in organically-labeled products and continued market growth.”


For chickens, the new organic rules “prohibit physical alterations include de-beaking of birds, docking of cows’ tails, de-snooding, dubbing, and face branding of cattle, and mulesing of sheep.” They also provide clarity around “outdoor access” with the new rules stating that “organic birds be provided with year-round access to the outdoors” with “a sufficient number” of “appropriately distributed” doors so chickens can actually go outside. Plus the new rules define “outdoor space” as having “at least 50% soil covered with maximum vegetation suited to the time of year and climate.”

Mammals, such as cows and pigs, must have “space and freedom to lie down, turn around, stand up, fully stretch their limbs, and express normal patterns of behavior; and areas for bedding and resting must be sufficiently large, solidly built, and comfortable so that animals are kept clean and dry.” The new rules also require that farmers “maintain the maximum amount of vegetation on outdoor soil, as appropriate for the season, climate, geography, and species of livestock. All producers must provide year-round access to the outdoors. For ruminants, such as cows, sheep, and goats, producers must provide pasture during the grazing season to meet previously established requirements.”

Source: https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/OLPPWebinarSlidesScript.pdf

In January 2017, President Trump tapped former Georgia Governor Sonny Perdue as his pick for secretary of the U.S. Department of Agriculture. Perdue (no relation to Perdue chicken) is expected to be confirmed by the Senate today (April 24, 2017). It remains to be seen if any organic certification rules will change.

Source: http://www.npr.org/2017/04/24/525359270/senate-to-vote-on-sonny-perdue-as-trumps-agriculture-secretary

If you'd like to see how Tyner Pond Farm promotes animal ethics and regenerative agriculture every day, come visit our farm in Greenfield. We’d love to show you around and introduce you to our animals!

Related Posts

You’re Buying Nutrition, Not Calories: Understanding Nutrient Density

At Tyner Pond Farm, we often hear questions about the cost of our grass-fed beef. We understand this concern—especially since so many of us...
Post by Chris Baggott
Sep 25 2024

The Nutritional Superiority of Grass-Fed Beef: A Comprehensive Look at Dr. Stephan Van Vliet’s Research

Recent research conducted by Dr. Stephan Van Vliet and his team represents a pivotal study in understanding the nutritional differences between grass-fed and conventional...
Post by Chris Baggott
Sep 24 2024

Another Frustrating Food Story Unraveled: Why You Should Read "Dark Calories"

Six weeks ago, I began a journey that has truly transformed the way I approach food and nutrition. My inspiration came partly from Dark...
Post by Chris Baggott
Sep 22 2024

Think Your Meat is Antibiotic-Free? New Findings Suggest Otherwise

A recent article from Progressive Farmer has exposed a troubling issue in the meat industry: 20% of samples labeled as “raised without antibiotics” were...
Post by Chris Baggott
Sep 02 2024

Connecting with Your Food: Why Visiting Tyner Pond Farm Matters

Visit Tyner Pond Farm: See Sustainable Farming in Action We are all crushed with marketing buzzwords and greenwashing designed to mislead us.  By supporting...
Post by Chris Baggott
Jul 31 2024

Antitrust, Farmers & Community: The Hidden Costs of Corporate Mergers

The True Cost of Cheap Food I saw a story today defending large mergers like Kroger and Albertsons. What struck me was this quote...
Post by Chris Baggott
Jul 19 2024

Letters from a Farmer in Indiana #5: Reflections on Independence Day

As we celebrate Independence Day, I find myself thinking about the issues that faced our nation's founders and how those concerns echo in our...
Post by Chris Baggott
Jul 04 2024

The Importance of Food Security AND Environmental Health

Letters From An Indiana Farmer: The Importance of Food Security and Environmental Health In a time when media often profits by amplifying our differences,...
Post by Chris Baggott
Jun 22 2024